Friday, May 11, 2007

Can God create a rock so heavy He can not lift it?


This is an age-old silly question. Some folks resort to all sorts of rationalizations trying to answer this question. The simple answer to the question is that it is an invalid question. The question itself is contradictory, so it cannot be answered. Here's why.

It is a question with a 'yes' or 'no' answer. So lets break it down as statements affirming each possible answer.

Yes, an OMNIPOTENT God can create a a rock so heavy He CAN NOT lift it.

No, an OMNIPOTENT God CAN NOT create a a rock so heavy He can not lift it.

Do you see the contradiction now? Each statement is affirming something that an omnipotent God can not do. So neither statement can ever be true since as soon as it is, it contradicts itself. So no matter how we answer this question, the answer is always self refuting and false. And there lies the invalidity of the question. It cannot be properly answered.

It is similar to the statement "I always lie." As soon as it's true, it contradicts itself just like our two possible options above when answering this silly question.